Client: An employee made a physical threat toward a coworker. I’m shaken and I know this is serious. How should I handle this?
Consultant: You’re right—this is one of the most serious situations you’ll face. Step one is immediate action: place the employee on administrative leave right away. Whether that leave is paid or unpaid depends on state law and your policies. Some states require paid leave during investigation, others allow unpaid—so you’ll want to confirm before acting. The key is removing the individual from the workplace immediately to protect everyone.
Client: So, I can’t just move straight to termination?
Consultant: Not yet. Even if the threat feels obvious, you need to conduct an investigation first. Administrative leave creates space for that. Document the reported threat, interview witnesses, and review any available evidence—emails, security footage, or statements. It shows you’re being thorough, not reactive.
Client: What if my team is scared this person might come back during the investigation?
Consultant: That’s a valid concern. Once on leave, notify the employee in writing:
“Effective immediately, you are on administrative leave pending investigation. Do not return to the workplace until contacted.”
At the same time, make sure access to systems, keys, and ID badges are deactivated. This isn’t punishment—it’s a safety measure.
Client: Okay. And if the investigation proves the threat happened?
Consultant: Separation is the next step, if consistent with policy or past practice. You can move forward with termination confidently because you’ve confirmed the facts. Keep the conversation short and professional, usually over the phone or video for safety:
“Based on the investigation, your employment is being terminated effective today. Your final paycheck will be delivered by [method] on [date]. Do not return to the workplace.”
Client: Do I really have to let them come in for their paycheck?
Consultant: No—and in this situation, you shouldn’t. Most states allow alternative delivery methods—direct deposit, certified mail, or courier service. The law requires you to meet the deadline for final pay, not to hand it over in person. Given the risk, keeping them offsite is probably best.
Client: What about the rest of my staff? They already know something happened.
Consultant: Address it quickly, without details:
“We had a situation, and it’s been handled. Everyone’s safety is a priority, and appropriate steps have been taken.”
This reassures your team while keeping the process confidential.
Client: So, the right order is: leave first, investigate, then separate if the threat is confirmed?
Consultant: Exactly. Safety, compliance, and fairness—those three guideposts will protect both your employees and your organization. The leave ensures safety, the investigation ensures fairness, and the termination—if warranted—ensures accountability.
If you ever face a high-risk situation like this, don’t navigate it alone. We can help review your state’s leave rules, guide you through the investigation process, and support you in managing separation logistics securely and legally. Safety first, compliance always.